Featured Case Studies
Blog

AI Revolution – Gen AI v TAR 1.0 – Is There a Difference?

By: Jeff Johnson, Chief Innovation Officer

TAR – More Process than Technology

AI Washing is likely a phrase you’ve heard at least once in recent months. It refers to exaggerations or false claims around the use of AI in products or services.

I didn’t hear the term in the 2000’s but you could say that “TAR Washing” was common then. Some offered to provide TAR solutions by claiming the “T” in Technology Assisted Review could include technology like concept clusters, near duplicate detection, email threading etc. This was a stretch.

Technology Assisted Review, or TAR, means something more specific than the generic definition of those three words. Yes, many technologies can assist a review. That does not make them TAR.

From the start, TAR signified specific processes that harnessed people and technology to “classify” documents in one of two buckets (most commonly responsive or not responsive).

It is appropriate to view our most common TAR workflows as substantially technology-agnostic.

Gen AI is TAR (or at least can be)

For the same reason utilizing email threading is not TAR, utilizing Gen AI IS TAR (or at least can be).

As noted above, process is the more fundamental aspect of TAR, as opposed to any specific technology or algorithm. The evolution of TAR disclosures, so that they focus on process and validation steps far more than technology selection, supports this assertion.

As tools applying Gen AI to eDiscovery review hit the market, we have to maintain the critical “human in the loop” in two key ways:

  1. Human input, in the form of, review protocol documentation or prompting
  2. Qualified validation that fulfills our ethical obligation to supervise

The common best practice recommendation for item 1 is the application of the Gen AI solution to a sample of a few hundred documents for which correct human review decisions exist, comparison of AI suggestions to those decisions, and iterative updates to the Gen AI prompting until it performs well on the sample. This prompt development step in a Gen AI TAR workflow occupies the same position as model training in a TAR workflow based on Machine Learning AI.

As for item 2, the same processes we’ve developed to validate a TAR review are likely the best method for this too.

You may have already predicted where I’m headed with this but I do enjoy saying it explicitly…

The most commonly documented/recommended way to use GenAI tools in automating eDiscovery review today is essentially TAR 1.0.

To be clear, I’m not suggesting that is a bad thing or that there is nothing new here. Not at all. I take three points from it:

  1. All the same concerns we have with TAR 1.0 production without eyes on documents, etc have to be dealt with in a Gen AI-automated review
  2. Perhaps the integration of yet another new technology will help us realize that a TAR 1.0 workflow enabled by 2024 technology is far better than a TAR 1.0 workflow based on 2004 state of the art…. And sometimes it is simply the right workflow to use.
  3. As this realization gains traction, it has the potential to increase a willingness to try Gen AI automated review, reduce the need for new precedent, and ultimately speed adoption of this new technology (we’ll save the discussion about cost for another day 😊)    

The Bottom line

The use of Gen AI tools in automating eDiscovery review represents an evolution (NOT a replacement) of a traditional TAR process utilizing a dramatically different technology governed by the same structured process and validation steps. Understanding this concept should help us (a) better understand how to develop the process (b) accelerate the adoption of this new technology and (c) position ourselves to take the best advantage of Gen AI’s growing capabilities in the eDiscovery process.

Contact us to learn more.

Tags
ai chat ai chatgpt document review ediscovery
Back to Blog

© Copyright 2023 Purpose, All rights reserved

It’s a self-appointed nickname, but it rings true. Our elite team approaches each project with precision, offering bespoke solutions that align with your objectives.

This will close in 0 seconds

Expect over-communication and real-time feedback, keeping you informed every step of the way.

This will close in 0 seconds

Leveraging AI and analytics for efficient review and quality control.

This will close in 0 seconds

With services in multiple languages and a dedicated review team in India, we handle international and multilingual projects effortlessly.

This will close in 0 seconds

Your data’s security is our top priority, with protocols that exceed industry standards.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal has the capability to process thousands of documents across nearly every data type each hour. Our technology accelerates the production of ready-to-review files, enabling faster response times in critical review scenarios.

This will close in 0 seconds

Save significant manual administrative time with our automated redaction capabilities. Effortlessly redact personally identifiable information (PII) across multiple documents and spreadsheets with our bulk-redaction tools.

This will close in 0 seconds

Build accurate searches with confidence. Purpose Legal uses intuitive technology that supports highly detailed queries, offering accessible and clickable terms for efficient review.

This will close in 0 seconds

There is no project too large or too small. Purpose Legal creates customized workflows to perfectly suit our clients’ needs, ensuring they achieve their objectives with our comprehensive support.

This will close in 0 seconds

We believe in overcommunication to ensure you never face the unknown. Our reports provide data and insights, mapping out clear options and their implications for your business. With Purpose Legal, you’ll always know the status of your project and the impact of your decisions.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our dedicated team in India specializes in insurance defense matters. Our expertise also extends to supporting plaintiff firms in class action lawsuits. Our team boasts long-term loyalty and a broad language capability—including Mandarin, Japanese, and more—ensuring we meet global needs.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal reviewers undergo extensive training on the specific issues and technologies of each project. Our real-time feedback and performance evaluations ensure a continuously improving team, ready to handle any challenge.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our review methodology is meticulous from start to finish, ensuring quality control through advanced analytics and AI processes. From project initiation to final quality checks, we implement a rigorous process to guarantee the highest standards of review quality.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Monitoring and Enforcement: Vigilant monitoring and enforcement of applicable data protection laws and regulations.
  • Updates and Awareness: Regular updates to our Privacy Compliance Program and the promotion of workforce awareness of data protection risks and rights.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Unauthorized Access Prevention: Implementation of controls to protect against unauthorized access to data, including internal controls for cyber threat detection.
  • Access Controls and Authentication: Strong access controls and multi-level user authentication are needed to ensure authorized access to data only.
  • Encryption and Secure Storage: Data encryption and secure, access-controlled data storage environments.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Minimization of Data Processing: Ensuring minimal personal data processing and maintaining comprehensive records of processing activities.
  • Incident and Breach Management: Procedures for incident and data breach management, with periodic updates to stay compliant.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Vendor Compliance: Periodic review of vendor contracts for compliance with data protection laws and oversight of critical vendors.
  • Contractual Obligations Review: Regular review and updates of contractual obligations to ensure compliance.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Cyber Simulations: Conducting periodic cyber simulations to evaluate readiness for cyber incidents.
  • Security Audits: Regular security audits, including penetration testing and vulnerability scanning, to identify and address vulnerabilities.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Client Consent: Preventing the sharing, sale, or disclosure of client data without express consent.
  • Use Limitation: Limiting the use of client data to approved business purposes and ensuring secure, VPN-based virtual desktop reviews.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Remote Connectivity: Utilizing Accops remote connectivity tools with stringent controls on screenshots, copy/paste, and USB access.
  • Firewall Implementation: Use of firewall systems to authenticate incoming network connections and separate networks.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Comprehensive Training: Providing extensive training on data security best practices, phishing recognition, and secure protocol adherence.
  • Security Awareness Programs: Regular programs to reinforce data security practices among employees involved in document review.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Privacy Risk Management: Use policy to manage and monitor legal risks and compliance requirements around privacy and data management.
  • Privacy Rights Requests: Maintaining records of Individual Privacy Rights requests and informing clients of such requests.

This will close in 0 seconds

  • Assessment of Risks: Conducting risk and business impact assessments to determine necessary levels of authentication and security measures.
  • Dial-Back Procedures: Implementing dial-back controls for protection against unauthorized connections.

This will close in 0 seconds

With forensic collections and investigation, “it depends” isn’t a non-answer—it’s the starting point of our precision-tailored strategy. Our experts know the questions to ask to get to the heart of your “it depends” and find the answers you need. What data is crucial? Which platforms are involved? What are the legal implications?

This will close in 0 seconds

Our expertise shines in our adaptability. Whether you’re dealing with enterprise-level cloud storage or specialized communication tools, we tailor our methods to suit the platform, the data, and the stakes of your case.

This will close in 0 seconds

Forensic investigations (physical and electronic) require everything below the surface, uncovering artifacts, time stamps, movement, behavior, and exfiltration. We specialize in the normalization or parsing of data so you can understand it and use it to your advantage.

This will close in 0 seconds

When we talk to clients, we often hear “I didn’t know I didn’t know that.” And frankly, you don’t need to—that’s what we are here for. You care about the output of the data you must review and that WE know how to do it. We will handle the heavy lifting so you feel confident that the process is being handled quickly, efficiently, and producing the evidence you need.

This will close in 0 seconds

While the process may be complex, our communication isn’t. We provide clear, comprehensible explanations, so you understand the rationale behind our approach and how it’s the best fit for your case. You are never confused or in the dark.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our methodology guarantees comprehensive coverage and defensibility. It’s that simple.

This will close in 0 seconds

With over twenty years of trial-tested experience, Purpose’s computer forensics examiners can offer expert testimony, either in court or through deposition, to explain complex, technical concepts in layman’s terms, as well as present electronic evidence in a clear and comprehensible manner.

This will close in 0 seconds

We decipher the most complex data, offering you fast, accurate insights. Stay ahead with our innovative tools and methodologies, prescribed specifically to your needs and goals.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our attorneys are proficient in reviewing and redlining contracts based on established playbooks, which we can develop in collaboration with our clients. This ensures that the contract review process is both efficient and aligned with client-specific standards and expectations.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal has extensive experience with a variety of specialized contract management tools including, Concord, Contract Sage, Wrangler, CS, Workiva, and more. Our team is skilled in utilizing these tools to offer cloud-based platforms, central repositories for contracts, workflow management for contract review and approval, collaboration tools, dashboards for tracking and reporting, e-signatures, and contract risk management detection.

This will close in 0 seconds

We provide contract drafting services based on templates, ensuring consistency and compliance with legal standards and client requirements. Our approach is flexible, allowing for customization based on specific client needs.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our team has tested and trained on leading contract management tools like Brevia, Luminance, ContractWorks, etc., which feature Al-enabled capabilities for auto-extracting key contract data points. We understand that while these tools provide a solid foundation, manual review and additional tagging are essential for accuracy and comprehensiveness.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal offers a highly customizable solution that can include but isn’t limited to the following:

  • Email or FTP for contract review and data extraction, with data organized into client-approved Excel templates.
  • Support for contract review and data extraction via Relativity, with custom data fields and OCR search capabilities.
  • In-house tool utilization for data review or template preparation for data import.

This will close in 0 seconds

From pre-M&A due diligence contract review to lease abstraction, playbook creation, and data extraction, Purpose Legal has the expertise to support a wide range of contract management services. Our team is capable of drafting and reviewing a variety of contracts, from NDAs to loan agreements and beyond, with an emphasis on identifying and managing nonstandard clauses.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal excels in creating best-in-class playbooks that streamline the contracting process, drawing on our deep experience and best practices to produce effective, client-specific playbooks.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our team includes seasoned Senior and Junior Indian Attorneys, providing reliable, efficient service with a proven track record of low error rates and high throughput, thanks to our focus on full-time, dedicated employees.

This will close in 0 seconds

NexGen Managed Services are designed to cater to your unique needs, whether you’re looking for Self-Service, Full-Service, or a tailored combination of both. Our Hybrid Approach seamlessly integrates skilled people and cutting-edge technology to support your operations, whether they’re cloud-based, housed in a data center, or on-premises. We offer robust infrastructure, ensuring that you have the dedicated environment you need to thrive without the complexities of a multi-tenant setup. For those who prefer a more human touch, our people-only option puts our expert team at your disposal.

This will close in 0 seconds

Our Configurable Tech Stack is designed with diversity and adaptability at its core. To streamline integration and ensure seamless data flow, we provide sophisticated middleware and data conversion solutions. We don’t compromise on storage, ensuring your data is always at hand when you need it. Security is paramount, with robust measures in place to protect your information. Our commitment to business continuity means that your operations keep running smoothly, no matter what.

This will close in 0 seconds

All of our solutions are bolstered by a team of experts who bring a wealth of knowledge to every project. We excel in Processing and Culling, streamlining data for efficiency. Our experts are dedicated to Forensics Collections and Investigations, ensuring thoroughness and accuracy. Our Advanced Technology harnesses cutting-edge tools to provide smarter, faster outcomes. Our Project Management acumen ensures that every project is executed flawlessly. With secure Data Hosting, we keep your data accessible and safe. Our NexGen Managed Review services blend expertise with precision, and our Consulting services provide strategic insights to drive your projects forward. The final touch to our services includes productions that meet all legal standards.

This will close in 0 seconds

Client Enablement is at the core of our approach, beginning with the creation of a personalized playbook to guide clients through complex scenarios. We ensure a smooth transition with comprehensive onboarding and implementation, setting the stage for success. Our workflow standardization makes operations efficient and predictable. We assign dedicated Project Management teams to maintain a consistent, high-touch service experience. Management of infrastructure, licenses, updates, upgrades, and patching is handled meticulously to keep client systems optimal without interruptions.

This will close in 0 seconds

Metrics That Matter form a critical feedback loop with an emphasis on both reporting/metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs). We provide tools to track backward & forward-looking metrics, enabling clients to assess past performance while anticipating future trends and outcomes. Our approach ensures that decision-makers are well-equipped with actionable data to drive continuous improvement and strategic planning.

This will close in 0 seconds

We aim to distinguish our services with a unique blend of expertise and innovation. Our team of AI & TAR experts push the envelope in technology research and testing. Our rigorous expert training and consulting services complement our team’s expertise, as do our product and application developers, who tailor solutions to meet the specific needs of each client.

This will close in 0 seconds

By redefining the traditional view of services as a Profit Center rather than a Cost Center, we focus on value creation. Our models ensure clients understand the financial impact. We offer clear Contract Termination Clauses and the flexibility to tier up and down in service levels without the worry of burst fees, providing cost control and predictability. Our pricing structures also include no burst fees for unexpected usage spikes and a commitment to cost predictability, so there are no surprises.

This will close in 0 seconds

We understand that the right technology can vary from case to case, which is why we provide access to a broad spectrum of leading eDiscovery and legal technology platforms. This breadth of choice ensures that you can always select the tool (or tools) that best fits your needs without the constraints of single-platform limitations.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal sees the need for our industry to evolve beyond outdated practices and rigid contracts.
We don’t believe in forcing clients into non-flexible, 3- to 5-year contracts. We want to demonstrate our value continuously, proving ourselves indispensable month after month.
Flexibility and a cutting-edge tech stack are the backbone of our NexGen Managed Services.

This will close in 0 seconds

In just a few clicks, our technology can help you easily send notices to unlimited custodians, track compliance, issue reminders, and even preserve in place for Microsoft Office365.

This will close in 0 seconds

Automate your legal hold process with our user-friendly technology. Standardize every step, from issuing holds to reporting, with powerful dashboards and seamless integration with HR and matter management systems—no IT infrastructure needed.

This will close in 0 seconds

Easily create and access records of your compliance efforts anytime, allowing for customized reporting and enhanced accountability.

This will close in 0 seconds

Minimize manual administrative tasks and mitigate risk through automated notifications and reminders, ensuring custodians respond efficiently.

This will close in 0 seconds

Navigating data privacy regulations like GDPR, CCPA, and emerging global standards requires a proactive approach. Purpose Legal empowers your organization to meet—and exceed—compliance standards with ease. Our solutions are designed to handle any volume of privacy-related inquiries, such as Digital Subject Access Requests (DSAR) ensuring you can meet quick turnaround times without compromising on budget or quality.

This will close in 0 seconds

We equip you with the tools to sift through vast amounts of information quickly, identifying and securing the specific data you need to protect your privacy and comply with regulations.

This will close in 0 seconds

Purpose Legal’s automated redaction technology reduces manual administrative tasks by enabling bulk redactions across documents and spreadsheets, including the sensitive handling of personally identifiable information (PII).

This will close in 0 seconds